Emile Dillon and Alfred Loisy. On the History of Catholic Modernism

The paper examines the relationship between an Irish journalist and special correspondent for London’s The Daily Telegraph Emile Dillon who spent many years in Russia and a French priest Alfred Loisy who was excommunicated because of his involvement into the Catholic Modernism movement. The study draws upon the extensive correspondence between Dillon and Loisy, preserved in their archives in France, UK, and the USA. Information regarding Dillon and Loisy found in their correspondence with other individuals was also utilized. The exchange between Dillon and Loisy was characterized by mutual trust and confidentiality. It allows us to follow the undercover support Dillon provided to Loisy, as Dillon operated under pseudonyms. The motives driving Loisy’s scholarly endeavors were less a matter of academic pursuit than of opportunistic pragmatism. Loisy suspended his revisionist interpretation of the Scriptures when the opportunity arose for him to become a bishop; conversely, he entered into open conflict with Rome when doing so became a prerequisite for securing a professorship at the Collège de France, given the anticlerical policy of the Third Republic of Belle Epoque. Dillon expressed his sympathy for Loisy’s views under a pseudonym, as openly supporting Loisy could have jeopardized his position as the The Daily Telegraph’s special correspondent in the countries where he was stationed.

1. Bécamel, M. (1968) « Autres lettres de Loisy à Mgr Mignot », Bulletin de littérature ecclésiastique 69(4): 241-268.

2. Burnham, E. (1955) Peterborough Court. The Story of The Daily Telegraph. London: Cassel & Company Ltd.

3. Chumakova T. (2020) Russian scholars of late 19th – early 20th centuries on religious modernism // Nauka o religii v Rossii: ot proshlogo k buduschemu. St Petersburg, p. 24-32 (in Russ.)

4. Dolgov V.B. (2012) Modernist theology of Alfred Loisy on Pentateuch // Vestnik Russkoi khristianskoi gumanitarnoi akademii. Т. 13, № 4. P. 13-21. (in Russ.)

5. Galkinа О.I. (2024) "Enemies of law and order": british journalists on Russian bureaucracy of late 19th – early 20th centuries // Istoricheskii opyt mirovykh zivilizatsii i Rossia. Vladimir. P. 62-68. (in Russ.)

6. Gorunov I.А. (2020) Western modernism and theology of Alfred Loisy // Sbornik trudov Yakutskoi dukhovnoi seminarii. № 7. P. 47-55. (in Russ.)

7. Lanfrey, A. (2003) Sécularisation, séparation et guerre scolaire : Les catholiques français et l'école (1901-1914). Paris : Éditions du Cerf.

8. Lannoy, A. (2020) Alfred Loisy and the Making of History of Religions. A Study of the Development of Comparative Religion in the Early 20th Century. Berlin et Boston. Religionsgeschichtliche Versuche und Vorarbeiten. Vol. 74. De Gruyter

9. Loisy, A. (1930) Mémoires pour servir à l'histoire religieuse de notre temps. T. I. 1857-1900. Paris : Emile Nourry.

10. Loisy, A. (1931) Mémoires pour servir à l'histoire religieuse de notre temps. T. II. 1900-1908; T. III. 1908-1927. Paris : Emile Nourry.

11. Меtеl О.V. (2012) Alfred Loisy on origins of Christianity // Belye piatna rossiskoi i mirovoi istorii. 2012. № 5-6. P. 26-37. (in Russ.)

12. Меtеl О.V. (2013) Alfred Loisy and his time // Vestnik Оmskоgо univesiteta. № 1(67). P. 48-52. (in Russ.)

13. Меtеl О.V. (2014) Problem of freedom of study in Catholic Church: E. Renan and А. Loisy // Vestnik Russkoi khristianskoi gumanitarnoi akademii. Т. 15, № 3. P. 118-129. (in Russ.)

14. O’Connell, M.R. (1994) Critics on Trial. An Introduction to the Catholic Modernist Crisis. Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press.

15. Portier, W. (2018) “Indiana Jones and the Modernist Crisis: E.J. Dillon's Pseudonymous Liberal Catholic Campaign, 1892-1902”, Modernism. Rivista annuale di storia del riformismo religioso in età contemporanea. Anno IV: 110-131.

16. Rafter, K. (2011) “E.J. Dillon: from our special correspondent”, in: K. Rafter (ed.) Irish Journalism Before Independence. More a Disease than a Profession, pp. 91–105. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press.

17. Ratté, K. (1967) Three Modernists. Alfred Loisy, George Tyrrell, William L. Sullivan. New York: Wheed and Ward.

18. Sardella, L.-P. (2004) Mgr Eudoxe Irénée Mignot (1842-1918). Un évêque français au temps du modernisme. Paris: Éditions du Cerf.

19. Sokolovskaya О.V. (2020) Emile Dillon, Anglo Russian scientist and his US archive // Slavianskii almanakh. 2020. № 3–4. P. 473–491. (in Russ.)

20. Тretiakovа S. N. (2016) "Peacekeeper" or "scourge of Europe"? Two contemporary British estimates of Alexander III. // Аktualnye voprosy istoricheskoi nauki. Каzan. P. 42-48. (in Russ.)

21. Ulunian А.А. (2015) Romania: 1916. British evaluation and prognosys // Slavianovedenie. № 3. P. 3-16. (in Russ.)

22. Vidler, A.R. (1970) A Variety of Catholic Modernists. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

23. Vоrоntsovа I.V. (2017) Catholic modernism (1890-1914) and Alfred Loisy // Istoricheskie issledovania. № 3(8). P. 315-331. (in Russ.)

24. Yellice, G. (2021) Türk-Yunan İlişkilerinde Dönüm Noktası: Birinci Dünya Savaşı Arifesinde Osmanlı Devleti ile Yunanistan’ın “Normalleşme” Arayışı ve Almanya’nın İttifak Projesi” // Stratejik ve Sosyal Araştırmalar Dergisi Türk-Yunan İlişkileri Özel Sayısı, C. 5, 30 Ağustos 2021, s.91-115.

25. Zhukov К.А. (2000) Emile Dillon, Russian orientology and Eastern question // Vostok: istoriia i kultura. Petersburg. P. 60-66. (in Russ.)

26. Zürrer, W. (1981) „Die griechisch-türkischen Beziehungen im Rahmen der Großen Politik 1909-1914“ Südost-Forschungen. 40: 104-143.