Concordat policy of Bavaria from the Napoleonic Wars to the Weimar Republic
https://doi.org/10.15829/2686-973X-2025-183
EDN: UABKBD
Abstract
This article analyses the relationship between Bavaria and the Holy See from 1802 to 1925, tracing developments from the secularisation of Bavaria to the entry into force of the Second Bavarian Concordat. In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, Bavaria played a leading role in the history of concordats between the Holy See and the German states. Particular attention is given to the Concordat of 5 June 1817, concluded between Pope Pius VII and King Maximilian I Joseph of Bavaria, and the Concordat of 29 March 1924, signed by Pius XI and the Bavarian state. The study examines the political and ecclesiastical circumstances that shaped these agreements and assesses their significance for Bavaria, Germany, and the Catholic Church. Owing to the Bavarian government’s assertion of supremacy in religious affairs, the 1817 Concordat was constrained by the Religious Edict of 1818, which subordinated the Church to the state; consequently, church–state relations until 1918 depended heavily on the position of the monarch and his ministers. The 1924 Concordat, grounded in the Weimar Constitution of 1919, proved advantageous to both parties: it affirmed Bavaria’s autonomy vis-à-vis the central government in Berlin and secured for the Catholic Church a substantial role in education and in episcopal appointments. Remaining in force to the present day, it has made a lasting contribution to the development of German church–state law and served as a model for regulating relations between the Catholic Church and German states in the twentieth century.
About the Author
M. V. Shelegin
M.V. Lomonosov Northern (Arctic) Federal University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Mikhail V. Shelegin — Postgraduate student, Department of General History
Arkhangelsk
References
1. Acta Apostolicae Sedis 1921 — Acta Apostolicae Sedis 13 (1921). Typis polyglottis Vaticanis, Romae, 521-524.
2. Böck 1989 — Böck, K. (1989). The amendment of the Bavarian Concordat of 1968. The end of the disputes about the confessional school and the legal protection of Catholic education in Bavaria, Augsburg. p. 28. (In German)
3. Brechtel 2024 — Brechtel, L. M. (2024). The re-establishment of the Cathedral chapter in Speyer as a result of the Bavarian Concordat of 1817. NomoK@non. (In German) doi:10.5282/nomokanon/283.
4. Dambacher 2020 — Dambacher, J. (2020). The negotiations on the Prussian Concordat of 1929. With special consideration of the Roman acts, Würzburg. p. 1153. (In German)
5. Deutsch 1963 — Deutsch, J. (1963). Some Problems of Church and State in the Weimar Constitution. The Yale Law Journal, 72(3), 457-474. doi:10.2307/794565.
6. Die Verfassung 1919 — The Constitution of the German Empire (11. August 1919). Reichsgesetzblatt, Nr. 152, 1383-1418. (In German)
7. Edikt über die äusseren Rechtsverhältnisse 1809 — Edict on the external legal relations of the inhabitants of the Kingdom of Bavaria, in relation to religion and ecclesiastical societies, for the more detailed determination of §§ VI of the first title of the Constitution (June 14, 1809). Königlich-Baierisches Regierungsblatt. XL. Stück, 897-920. (In German)
8. Heun 2020 — Heun, W. (2020). State services to churches and other religious communities, in Pirson, D., Rüfner, W., Germann, M. and Muckel, S. (eds.), 3, Handbuch des Staatskirchenrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 3017-3071. (In German)
9. Heinritzi 2010 — Heinritzi, F. (2010). The reorganization of the relationship between the state and the Church in Bavaria after the First World War. Genesis and significance of the Bavarian Concordat of 1924/25, in Zedler, J. (ed.), Der Heilige Stuhl in den internationalen Beziehungen 1870–1939, Herbert Utz Verlag, München, 203-226. (In German)
10. Hohl 2024 — Hohl, H. (2024). The Bavarian Concordat of 1817. NomoK@non. (In German) doi:10.5282/nomokanon/272.
11. Huber 1988 — Huber, E. R., and Huber, W. (1988). State and Church in the 19th and 20th centuries Documents on the history of German state church law. Bd. IV: State and Church in the time of the Weimar Republic, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin. p. 884. (In German)
12. Huber 1990 — Huber, E. R., and Huber, W. (1990). State and Church in the 19th and 20th centuries. Documents on the history of German state church law. Bd. I: State and Church from the end of the Old Reich to the eve of the bourgeois revolution, 2, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin. p. 705. (In German)
13. Kämper 2020 — Kämper, B. and Schulten, M. (2020). The self-determination of churches and other religious communities over their assets, in Pirson, D., Rüfner, W., Germann, M. and Muckel, S. (eds.), 3, Handbuch des Staatskirchenrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 2819-2887. (In German)
14. Kapfelsperger 2016 — Kapfelsperger, T. (2016). State services to the Catholic Church in Bavaria: basics, development since 1919 and possible replacement, EOS-Verlag. p. 328. (In German)
15. Kotulla 2007 — Kotulla, M. A. (2007). German Constitutional Law 1806-1918 A collection of documents and introductions. Bd. 2: Bavaria, Springer, Berlin. p. 2038. (In German)
16. Kraus 2007 — Kraus, Hans-Christof (2007). The end of old Germany. Crisis and dissolution of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation 1806, Duncker & Humblot GmbH, Berlin. p. 124. (In German)
17. Listl 1996a — Listl, J. (1996). The concordatary development in Bavaria from 1817 to 1988, in Isensee, J. and Rüfner, W. (eds.), Kirche im freiheitlichen Staat: Schriften zum Staatskirchenrecht und Kirchenrecht, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 544-590. (In German)
18. Listl 1996b — Listl, J. (1996). The redefinition of diocesan registration in the reunified Germany, in Isensee, J. and Rüfner, W. (eds.), Kirche im freiheitlichen Staat: Schriften zum Staatskirchenrecht und Kirchenrecht, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 863-885. (In German)
19. Listl 1996c — Listl, J. (1996). Concordats and Church Treaties, in Isensee, J. and Rüfner, W. (eds.), Kirche im freiheitlichen Staat: Schriften zum Staatskirchenrecht und Kirchenrecht, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 469-493. (In German)
20. Listl 1996d — Listl, J. (1996). State and Church in Germany. From Prussian General Land Law to the Bonn Basic Law, in Isensee, J. and Rüfner, W. (eds.), Kirche im freiheitlichen Staat: Schriften zum Staatskirchenrecht und Kirchenrecht, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 237-294. (In German)
21. Löhnig 2011 — Löhnig, M. and Preisner, M. (2011). Creating as many fait accompli as possible: For the validity and continuation of the Bavarian Concordat of 1924. Zeitschrift der Savigny-Stiftung für Rechtsgeschichte: Kanonistische Abteilung, 97(1), 219-273. (In German) doi:10.7767/zrgka.2011.97.1.219.
22. Mager 2020 — Mager, U. (2020). Promotion of churches and other religious communities by the state, in Pirson, D., Rüfner, W., Germann, M. and Muckel, S. (eds.), 3, Handbuch des Staatskirchenrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 2767-2798. (In German)
23. May 2017a — May, G. (2017). The Concordat policy of the Holy See from 1918 to 1974, in Egler, A. and Rees, W. (eds.), Schriften zu Staat und Kirche. Ausgewählte Aufsätze, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 515-564. (In German)
24. May 2017b — May, G. (2017). The church’s concerns in the current Bavarian school law of general education schools, in Egler, A. and Rees, W. (eds.), Schriften zu Staat und Kirche. Ausgewählte Aufsätze, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 9-32. (In German)
25. Mückl 2020 — Mückl, S. (2020). Contracts between the state and churches and other religious communities, in Pirson, D., Rüfner, W., Germann, M. and Muckel, S. (eds.), 3, Handbuch des Staatskirchenrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Duncker und Humblot, Berlin, 433-481. (In German)
26. "Placet" 1993 — Placet. (1993) New English-Russian dictionary. Volume 2. Мoscow, "Russkij jazyk", 702.
27. Stehlin 1983 — Stehlin, S. A. (1983). Weimar and the Vatican, 1919–1933: German-Vatican Diplomatic Relations in the Interwar Years, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. p. 490.
28. Treml 2006 — Treml, M. (2006). History of modern Bavaria: kingdom and Free State, 3, Bayerische Landeszentrale für politische Bildungsarbeit, München. p. 560. (In German)
29. Volk 1972 — Volk, L. (1972). The Reichskonkordat of July 20, 1933: from the beginnings in the Weimar Republic to the ratification on September 10, 1933, Matthias-Grunewald-Verlag, Mainz. p. 265. (In German)
30. Zedler 2024 — Zedler, J. (2024). An unloved child? Bavaria, the Holy See and the Concordat of 1817. zur debatte, 54(3), 14-19. (In German)
31. Bonvech 2008 — Bonvech, B. (2008). History of Germany. Vol. 1. From the earliest times to the creation of the German Empire, Belkovec L. P., Vasjutin S. A., Glushanin E. P. et al.; Bonvech B., Galaktionov Yu. V. (ed.).; Moscow, KDU Publ. 544 p. (In Russ.)
32. Vasilyev 2000 — Vasilyev, V. I. (2000). German Federalism: Problems of Development. Moscow, Kompaniya Sputnik Publ. p. 407. (In Russ.)
33. Grysa 2005 — Grysa, T. (2005). Concordat. Catholic Encyclopedia. Volume 2. Moscow, Izdatelstvo franciskancev Publ., 1223-1224. (In Russ.)
34. Popov 2023 — Popov, I. D. (2023). Bavaria and the Adoption of the Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University, History, 68(3), 743-758. (In Russ.)
35. Ribakov 2010 — Ribakov, V. A. (2010). Transform and implementation way of development national law. Herald of Omsk University. Series "LAW", (3), 34-41. (In Russ.)
36. Temnikovskiy 1911 — Temnikovskiy E. (1911). Concordat. The Orthodox Theological Encyclopedia or theological encyclopedic dictionary. Volume 12. Tovarishchestvo A. P. Lopuhina Publ., Saint Petersburg. 807-816. (In Russ.)
Review
For citations:
Shelegin M.V. Concordat policy of Bavaria from the Napoleonic Wars to the Weimar Republic. Russian Journal of Church History. 2025;6(3):129-147. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.15829/2686-973X-2025-183. EDN: UABKBD
Views:
55
Email this article 